Only once as finalist was the Bethlehem team eliminated and that was in the season 1916-17, when defeated by the Fall River Rovers in a game at Pawtucket, R. I., by the score of 1 to 0. Previous national final results were as follows:
1913-14 -- At Pawtucket, R. I., May 16, 1914; Brooklyn F. C., of Brooklyn, N. Y., 2, Brooklyn Celtic F. C., Brooklyn, N. Y., 1; Referee, Charles E. Creighton of New York City.
1914-15 -- At Taylor Stadium, Lehigh University, South Bethlehem. May 1, 1916; Bethlehem Steel F. C., of Bethlehem, 3, Brooklyn Celtic F. C., of Brooklyn, N. Y., 1; Referee, George Lambie of Boston, Mass.
1915-16 -- At Pawtucket, R. I., May 5th, 1916; Bethlehem Steel F. C., of Bethlehem, 1; Fall River Rovers of Fall River, Mass., 0; Referee, David M. White, of Brooklyn, N. Y.
1916-17 -- At Pawtucket, R. I., May 5th, 1917; Fall River Rovers of Fall River, Mass., 1, Bethlehem Steel F. C., of Bethlehem, 0; Referee, William Taylor of Pawtucket, R. I.
1917-18 -- At Pawtucket, R. I., May 4, 1918; Fall River Rovers of Fall River, Mass., 2, Bethlehem Steel F. C., of Bethlehem, 2; Referee, Charles E. Creighton of New York City. Played off at Harrison, N. J., May 19, 1918; Bethlehem Steel F. C., of Bethlehem, 3, Fall River Rovers of Fall River, Mass., 0; Referee, Charles E. Creighton of New York City.
1918-19 -- At Fall River, Mass., April 19, 1919; Bethlehem Steel F. C. of Bethlehem, 2, Paterson F. C., of Paterson, N. J., 0; Referee, George Lambie of Southbridge, Mass.
1919-20 -- At Federal League Park, St. Louis, Mo., May 9th, 1920; Ben Miller F. C. of St. Louis, Mo., 2, Fore River F. C. of Quincy, Mass., 1; Referee, Alexander McKenzie of Chicago, Ill.
1920-21 -- At Fall River, Mass., April 10, 1921; Robins Dry Dock F. C., of Brooklyn, N. Y., 4, Scullin Steel F. C., of St. Louis, Mo., 2; Referee, James Scholfield of Bristol, Conn.
1921-22 -- At St. Louis, Mo., March 19, 1922; Scullin Steel F. C. of St. Louis, Mo., 3, Todd Shipyards F. C. of Brooklyn, N. Y., 2; Referee, George Young, Philadelphia
* 1922-23 -- At Harrison, N. J., April 1, 1923; Paterson F. C., of Paterson, N. J., 2, Scullin Steel F. C., of St. Louis, Mo., 2; Referee, J. B. Stark of Detroit, Mich.
1923-24 -- At St. Louis, Mo., March 20, 1924; Fall River F. C. of Fall River, Mass., 4; Vesper Buick F. C. of St. Louis, Mo., 2; Referee, Edward McCabe of New York City.
1924-25 -- At Tiverton, R. I., April 19, 1925; Shawsheen S. C. of Andover, Mass., 3, Canadian Club F. C. of Chicago, Ill., 0; Referee, William Norse of New Bedford, Mass.
* Awarded by forfeit to Paterson F. C. of Paterson, N. J.